18
Sep 10

More (intelligent stuff) on Pope Benedict

Much of what is written and spoken about the Pope’s visit divides between intolerant yelling and worshipful sycophancy. But in between these two uninteresting extremes lies an opportunity for some journalism of ideas. Two more interesting examples.

  • An attack by Frank Furedi on Pope Benedict’s critics here. He has a point about the intolerance shown to the Pope but he’s overpitching it when he compares the attacks made by people like Richard Dawkins or Peter Tatchell to the intolerant fanatics of the past. The fact that many of the attacks on Benedict are conformist and unreflective doesn’t make them akin to the intolerance of the past. Calling your opponent evil or immoral in the past usually invited either the mob or the church authorities to force you to shut up. Today’s Pope-haters have only the weapon of words.
  • There’s only a day or two more to see this on iPlayer but I’d recommend this documentary on Benedict by Mark Dowd, an award-winning film-maker and activist who is gay and who once trained as a Dominican friar. Despite the fact that film is made in the compulsory current style in which the presenter is more important than the subject, Dowd overcomes these limitations and uses his unusual viewpoint to sketch some illuminating ideas about Catholicism today.
Share

13
Sep 10

The Pope in Britain: stuff you might have missed

The coverage of religion in news media is odd. Journalists in mainstream outlets tend to be dismissive of organised religion and frequently cite (clearly accurate) polls showing the decline in the numbers of the faithful and of church worship. Typical example here.

But religious and spiritual ideas – including agnostic and atheist arguments – and the struggles of the institutions which embody them speak to something beyond the daily round of news stories about politics and money. The sexual abuse cases haunting the Catholic church which reveal such astounding corruption of spiritual authority have had the effect of making that church better known throughout the world. Religion retains a capacity to occasionally move public events in surprising ways. When the Cold War was still a fact, who would have guessed that in the late 1980s a Polish Pope, John Paul II, would have been a factor in bringing about the largely peaceful collapse of the communist regimes? Ideas move slowly but powerfully.

Much of the best writing about organised religion isn’t in mainstream media but in magazines which are more user-friendly to ideas. Here are three pieces published in advance of Pope Benedict’s visit this week  and all of which contain rich added value to make you think.
Continue reading →

Share